Ouch! Why Does it Hurt?

Enduring the rigors of police work without the pain

 


 

James Di Naso | From the October 2007 Issue Sunday, September 30, 2007

You have only a half-hour left on your shift when you get the call. You hit the lights and siren as you speed to the destination. The dull, chronic pain you ve felt in your lower back from sitting in the cruiser the past three hours leaves your mind as the adrenaline starts dumping into your bloodstream. You reach the scene, jump out of the vehicle, sprint and wrestle down the offender. Another arrest with a successful outcome. But a few minutes later, the familiar pain in your lower back returns, and this time it s much worse.

Scenarios like this are all too common in the law enforcement profession. Officers painfully go through their careers and into retirement with all types of joint pain: low-back, shoulder, knee, ankle, hip and neck, to name a few. In fact, the quality of life for police officers once they reach retirement is poor compared to the average population. I used to think living with pain was just a normal part of the job, says Brian Marvin, a recently retired, 30-year law enforcement veteran and lead instructor for Police Kinesiology Company.

Unfortunately, this is the mentality of many officers, but the truth is, pain comes with a high cost. Departments and agencies spend millions of dollars each year in worker compensation claims, and the quality-of-life issues for officers are substantial. The good news: There are things we can do to prevent and manage the pain, its debilitating effect on careers and the economic strain on departments and agencies.

The problem is our profession is resistant to change and new ideas that come from the outside. Once I realized there was science out there that could help me manage and eventually eliminate my pain, I welcomed that change, says Marvin. The same science that has helped thousands of professional athletes prevent and rehabilitate injuries is now being adapted for law enforcement. Recent advances over the past 10 years in the fields of kinesiology (the study of human movement), exercise science and sports performance training are changing the way athletes and other career fields approach job preparation and training.

So, Why Does It Hurt?

First, you must have a basic understanding of the physical requisites of the job. Job descriptions within law enforcement vary, but these are some of the most common activities for a majority of those out on patrol:

Quickly getting in and out of the cruiser;

Sprinting short distances;

Physically restraining offenders;

Baton striking;

Pushing stalled vehicles;

Carrying heavy firearms;

Breaching doors;

Crawling through windows;

Climbing multiple flights of stairs;

Moving while wearing a vest and duty belt; and

Sitting and driving for extended periods of time.

These physical requisites of the job require adequate physical preparation. And although officers are getting hurt performing these tasks, they are not the root cause of the injuries and the subsequent pain that follows. In my own research and after speaking with hundreds of officers, I have found two main reasons that so many officers suffer from chronic pain: 1) a lack of physical preparation, and 2) the wrong kind of physical preparation.

A lack of physical training can cause muscle weaknesses, incorrect movement mechanics and eventual orthopedic injuries to the joints when performing basic job-related tasks. The use it or lose it principle applies here. A lack of physical training eventually brings about weakness in the muscles and connective tissue of the body. This makes an officer more susceptible to injury when a situation dictates the use of physical force or skills that require physical exertion. The muscles and connective tissue provide support to joints, and if they are not challenged regularly through physical training, they atrophy and grow weak. This compromises the entire stability of the joint complexes and structurally weakens the body. The problem is compounded when the officer must carry the additional weight of a duty belt and vest. This will commonly begin to manifest itself in the form of chronic pain in the knee, hip and low back.

The subsequent weakness can also have a very negative effect on the way an officer moves. Compensations in the way a person moves are directly related to muscle weakness. We ve seen officers who can t get up off the ground or stand upright from a seated position without severely compromising efficient movement skills. Even getting up out of the cruiser is a chore for many. This makes me wonder how the officer could utilize the defensive tactics or firearm-retention skills they ve learned if they were in a fight with a bad guy.

The wrong kind of physical training can prove just as problematic as a lack of physical training. Many officers, in a good-faith effort to physically prepare for the job, actually create muscle imbalances and increase the risk of injury out on the street by training incorrectly. Example: A patrol officer who spends a lot of time driving a cruiser can suffer from chronic shoulder pain due to the position of the officer s shoulders while holding onto the steering wheel during periods of prolonged sitting. This body position tends to round the back and bring the shoulders into a forward position. If the officer is performing a lot of bench pressing exercises and not performing exercises for the smaller muscles of the upper back and rotator cuff, a muscle imbalance will most likely occur. This imbalance will cause the muscles of the chest and shoulders to pull the shoulders forward to an even greater degree and weaken the muscles of the upper back. This will restrict shoulder mobility and increase the likelihood of shoulder injury when performing movements like reaching behind the seat for a firearm. Chronic shoulder pain now accompanies the officer while sitting and driving in the cruiser for long periods of time.

How Can You Manage & Prevent Pain?

I usually take a poll at the injury prevention courses I instruct and ask the officers, By a show of hands, how many here have had an on-duty or off-duty injury involving the low-back, shoulder, knee, ankle, hip, wrist or neck that required rehabilitation? A majority of the officers raise their hands. The second question I ask is, How many are still performing their rehabilitation exercises? Almost every time, the hands go down. Once a person has been injured, the chances of repeat injury to the same joint or muscle group is very high. The best way to prevent re-injury is to keep performing the rehabilitation exercises, but officers are just not doing them.

This is where the science comes in. Rehab exercises are not just for those who have had an injury. Strength and conditioning coaches who work with athletes know there s a high probability an athlete involved in a particular sport will get certain injuries. The same holds true for cops. Certain injuries tend to occur because of the physical requisites of the job. Officers can perform the rehabilitation exercises regardless of whether they have been previously injured as a way to prevent these common injuries. We call this type of training prehabilitation. Many of the same exercises performed to rehabilitate and strengthen an injured muscle group can prevent an injury.

In the sidebar Pre-habilitation Exercises (p. 44), you ll find some practical exercises that will help prevent many of the injuries associated with police work. The exercises are simple, yet very effective, and can be performed anywhere without any equipment.

Conclusion

Officers who understand the job requires adequate physical preparation don t have to endure a career or retirement filled with chronic pain.

A lack of physical training or the wrong kind of training can cause muscle weakness, incorrect movement mechanics and muscle imbalances, leading to eventual chronic pain and orthopedic injuries. Performing simple prehabilitation exercises two or three times a week can help prevent and minimize job-related injuries to the low-back, shoulder, knee, ankle, hip and neck. This will help improve an officer s job performance and quality of life, and reduce the economic drain on agencies and departments from high rates of workman s compensation claims.



Prehabilitation Exercises

Gallery 1

Opposite Arm & Leg Lifts - 1

This exercise will minimize the risk for low-back, neck and shoulder injury by strengthening the extensor muscles of the neck, erector muscles of the lower back, and the shoulder-stabilizer muscles. It’s an excellent exercise for preventing the chronic low-back and shoulder pain associated with extended periods of sitting while driving in the cruiser. Lie prone maintaining a neutral head position, and dorsiflex your ankles (toes toward shins). Keep your hands shoulder-width apart in a thumbs-up position.


Gallery 1

Opposite Arm & Leg Lifts - 2

Flex the shoulder and extend the hip by raising your right arm and left leg off the floor. Make sure to keep the ankles dorsiflexed throughout the exercise.


Gallery 1

Opposite Arm & Leg Lifts - 3

Return to the starting position and repeat the action with the opposite arm and leg for 10–25 repetitions.


Gallery 1

Jackknives -1

This exercise will minimize the risk of injury to the trunk by strengthening the abdominal muscles. This exercise is excellent for preventing hernias and strains to the anterior trunk caused by the lifting of heavy objects and compounded by carrying the weight of duty belt and body armor. Lie supine with your arms over your head and legs extended. Keep your ankles dorsiflexed.


Gallery 1

Jackknives - 2

Simultaneously flex the trunk and the left hip, bringing your arms forward while reaching toward your ankle.


Gallery 1

Jackknives - 3

Return to the starting position with the arms over the head and legs extended.


Gallery 1

Jackknives - 4

Repeat the action, flexing the right hip. Repeat for 10–25 repetitions.


Gallery 1

Leg Bucks -1

This exercise will minimize the risk of injury to your knees by strengthening the hamstring and gluteus muscles. This exercise re- educates the muscle of the lower body to work more efficiently to allow for safe and efficient movement skills involving squatting and lunging motions. Lie in a supine position and flex your knees. Maintain a 90-degree flexion of the knee joint and dorsiflexion of the ankle throughout the exercise.


Gallery 1

Leg Bucks - 2

Extend your hips by driving your heels into the floor. Pause in the extended position, then return to the starting position. Repeat for 10–20 reps.


Gallery 1

Russian Twists - 1

This exercise will minimize the risk of injury to the lower back and trunk by strengthening the muscles involved in trunk rotation. It will also enhance the physical qualities necessary for practicing safe defensive-tactics skills and preventing lower back injury caused by wrestling with an offender. Sit on the floor and flex your hips and knees at 90 degrees. Dorsiflex your ankles (toes toward shins) and bring the heels up off the floor.


Gallery 1

Russian Twists - 2

Rotate your trunk to the right, keeping your head in line with your torso and hands during the exercise.


Gallery 1

Russian Twists - 3

Rotate your trunk to the left, keeping your head in line with the torso and hands during the exercise. Repeat the side-to-side rotation for 10–25 repetitions.


Gallery 1

Single Leg Stands -1

This exercise will minimize the risk of injury to the ankle, knee and hip. It also improves balance and stability in the joints of the lower body to help prevent sprains and strains. Perform this exercise on a level surface. Start by placing your hands on your hips.


Gallery 1

Single Leg Stands - 2

Raise your right leg by flexing your hip and knee. Keep the ankle of the flexed leg dorsiflexed throughout the exercise. Hold this position for 10–60 seconds.


Gallery 1

Single Leg Stands - 3

Return to the starting position and repeat the exercise by flexing your left hip and knee. Hold this position for 10–60 seconds, and repeat the sequence 3–4 times.



Connect: Have a thought or feedback about this? Add your comment now
print share
 

James Di NasoJames Di Naso is co-owner of Police Kinesiology Company (www.pkcotraining.com) and serves as the company s Police Performance Director. Over the past several years, he has trained thousands of federal, state, county and city law enforcement officers. He has authored many articles on police specific fitness for various publications. He s also an instructor for North East Multi Regional Training (NEMRT), a regional police-training academy in Illinois, is a member of the International Law Enforcement Educators and Trainers Association (ILEETA) and has presented numerous times at the organizations annual conference. Prior to focusing on training law enforcement officers, Di Naso worked for 16 years as a sports performance coach training athletes at every level, including professional athletes from the NFL, NBA and MLB. He holds a Master degree in Exercise Science from Eastern Illinois University and professional certifications from the National Strength and Conditioning Association and the United States Weightlifting Federation.

BROWSE FULL BIO & ARTICLES >

What's Your Take? Comment Now ...

Product Connect

 

 

Subscribe to Law Officer

Print or Digital Edition


 

INTERNATIONAL SUBSCRIPTIONS
CLICK HERE >


 

Get LawOfficer in Your Inbox

 

Where's the Money?

Major project and equipment expenses need to be funded.
More >